Sometimes we can point to an immediate precipitating cause or injury and sometimes not. It sometimes perceives pain in response to stimuli that would normally be considered benign, or even with no external stimuli at all. This leads them to search for anatomical targets for intervention using corticosteroid injections, nerve blocks, or often-unnecessary surgeries. Squats and deadlifts, which use almost every big muscle in your body including all the little ones in your “core,” and which load and strengthen the spine itself, get stronger for years. Talk with your doctor about which activities you might try. Seriously, most people who are doing “Starting Strength Novice Progression” have never even read … Some backs that are badly degenerative on the MRI do not hurt, while some backs that are not terribly screwed up hurt all the time, and maybe hurt in places where there is nothing on the MRI that explains the pain. Fortunately, most forms of back pain get better on their own: approximately 50% of patients will experience back pain relief within two weeks and 90% within three months.. Regular low-impact aerobic activities — those that don't strain or jolt your back — can increase strength and endurance in your back and allow your muscles to function better. A competent, reassuring, and experienced coach can help guide gradual progress. Situps and tricks performed on a balance ball cannot do this, because they fail to load and strengthen the big muscle mass, and because they fail to challenge your ability to relearn important positional capability like these two important barbell exercises do. Pain: everyone has felt it, whether they train with barbells or not. As coaches, we get asked about aches and pains all the time, and since we like to analyze barbell training in terms of physics and classical mechanics, we’re tempted to treat the human body the same way when searching for an explanation for pain. Let’s now take a look at how this model applies to the current practice of musculoskeletal diagnosis and treatment. Benefits obtained from physical therapy as it is typically practiced are more likely due to the passage of time than targeted strengthening interventions on your gluteus medius. We carefully watch people move as though they were robots, looking for the “bolt” that’s loose, the “screw” that might be a bit too tight, or the “alignment” that’s just a bit off. The vast majority of them, me included, have experienced back pain from time to time. Our evolution has therefore demanded a large degree of tolerance for structural anomalies, asymmetries, and “bad posture” – at least much more than your chiropractor would have you believe. There you have it, folks. The primary problem with this anatomical variation is that human spines degenerate under their compressive environment over time – all of them. 3. Originally developed by a physical therapist, it is based on the idea that “most humans are significantly out of alignment with gravity,” (whatever that means), and that “bound up” fascia must be manually separated from muscle tissue to enhance function and emotional state. Based on the available evidence: tightness doesn’t consistently hurt, and pain doesn’t consistently “tighten” … or change a muscle’s texture at all. Note that I spent the past 5,000 words arguing that posture, structure, and mechanics alone are insufficient to explain pain, not that mechanics “don’t matter”. Biomechanics remain important when moving under the barbell, where the external load is amplifying the forces on your body’s tissues and therefore reducing their tolerance for gross deviations. Once again, before typing out your angry comments, understand that I’m arguing against the mechanical model and its associated pseudoscience, not whether you personally got relief from a massage or manual therapy. I started feeling some pain in my lower back on the last rep of my 230 squat, 3 sets of 5. But otherwise, despite their ominous names these spinal conditions have a very good long-term prognosis, and patients tend to experience substantial improvement over time regardless of whether they get surgery or not.[6,32]. Starting Strength is a strength training system designed to safely and efficiently improve strength, health, and athletic performance using basic barbell exercises. Most of them know this, and are conservative with surgical recommendations. But the thing he finds wrong may or may not be the cause of the pain, since everybody will have something wrong whether they have back pain or not. Although “tightness” was discussed above in the massage section, it’s also worth mentioning that hip flexor, hamstrings, and psoas tightness have shown no predictive value for the development of back pain in prospective trials. Of course, this is not how things actually work. This is because their spines are all constructed the same basic way, while they occupy different mechanical environments. Someone with chronic nonspecific back pain who has frequent “flare-ups” might become so afraid of worsening pain that their brain “learns” to hurt with progressively less range of motion, lowering their pain threshold to the point where it becomes too painful to even pull their socks on. Consider that before the next time you try to pressure your doctor into ordering a spinal MRI.[46]. You want a strong old human back, or a weak old human back? Starting Strength is a popular barbell lifting routine developed by Mark Rippetoe. In summary: When the doc says that, based solely on your MRI results, you should either get surgery or invest in a rolling walker, take some Vicodin, and definitely avoid lifting heavy weights so you don’t “blow your back out”… they’re probably wrong. Pain is therefore a projection of the brain. There are things you should do if you have back pain. [21] It has been suggested that the evidence for massage improving depression, anxiety, and feelings of stress might better explain the benefits observed for back pain. Upright is our normal posture between naps and shoeing horses. [6, 27-29] The presence on MRI of spinal stenosis, spondylolysis, and spondylolisthesis similarly have poor correlation with pain, as the majority of these conditions are actually asymptomatic (although they certainly can cause symptoms). Strength training Lower back pain often affects joints or connective tissues, so increasing muscle strength around these areas can help lessen the effects of the pain. Individuals with active and painful lower back pain symptoms will all … Your back is an old human back. Admittedly, this article presents generalized views of practice patterns in each field, and of course there are exceptions out there, practitioners who do good for their patients (some of whom are therapists I deeply respect), but they remain few and far between. Note: The current theories of pain neurobiology could fill volumes of text, so as a disclaimer I’ll just say that this section will provide a very brief and simplified overview of the topic in order to frame our subsequent discussion as it pertains to diagnosis and treatment. the “naming” of the sensation as pain – sensations that other people have too, since they have the aforementioned aging human spines, but which they do not interpret as “pain.” Deadlifting a progressively heavier barbell increases your confidence in your ability to perform normal human movements with your spine again, and dramatically alters your perception of pain as a result. Unfortunately, MRI-proven pathology has an incredibly poor correlation with symptom onset, severity, duration, or prognosis. you perceive localizing pain in proportion to the intensity of the signal, and then attach a “negative” interpretation to this sensation. Science, worthy of the Annals of Silly Bullshit. Think past the superficial to the cause of the problem: nothing can strengthen a weak back that is not strong enough to be stable better than an exercise that progressively strengthens the back while keeping it stable. 1) Not reading the book. The mechanical model views the body strictly as a machine-like system of levers where the slightest imperfection, anomaly, or asymmetry results in malfunction and pain. You can easily identify people out in public with head-forward postures (seen in UCS) or lordosis and anterior pelvic tilts (seen in LCS) who are asymptomatic from such hopelessly “bad posture”. Unfortunately the overwhelming evidence we have suggests that these purely structural findings correlate extremely poorly with pain. By the time you are a full-grown adult, something will have changed in your back that can be interpreted as a potential cause of back pain. They similarly take a history and perform a physical exam, where they lie you down on the table and examine the various soft tissues around your spine and hips. My absolute biggest problem with everything I’ve discussed so far, the thing that really pisses me off as a physician, is the fact that a desperate, anxious patient could present to every single one of these practitioners and potentially receive a different diagnosis. They’ll begin with an evaluation to see if the patient is appropriate for physical therapy – for example, making sure they don’t have unusual symptoms suggesting untreated systemic disease or other such causes for their pain. Although the available data shows a very low incidence of weightlifting-related injuries, I still don’t allow clients to deadlift with rounded backs, squat with caved-in knees, or bench press with wildly flared elbows (although when you think about it, people have done all of these things without pain). [1,30,31], So even though the MRI pictures are staring us in the face, we still can’t be confident that what we see is the sole cause of pain. The choice is yours. At this point they’ll subject the patient to a battery of physical assessments, measuring certain skeletal parameters, assessing soft tissue qualities, as well as basic strength, range of motion, flexibility, and a number of other tests. Nothing can teach a weak back that being stronger is better than the movements which both require and produce that strength. Living a healthy lifestyle is the … [20] And “myofascial / trigger point pain” does seem to describe a real (and likely underdiagnosed) phenomenon, although the mechanistic science of it is still unclear. If something concerning is found on initial examination, or if the pain has been persistent for several weeks, most will order an X-ray or MRI. [1,54-59] They won’t agree on what specific structure needs adjusting, release, strengthening, stabilizing, or whatever other intervention is fashionable. Unfortunately when it comes to pain, this sort of rigid mechanical analysis doesn’t always lead to a satisfying outcome in musculoskeletal diagnosis the way it does in barbell training, and in this article I hope to explain why. As a result of this fact, if the doctor happens to be a surgeon he can always find something to operate on – since there will always be something wrong he can see on the test. [2-5] This involves structural and physiological changes resulting in a hypersensitive nervous system that perceives pain far out of proportion to the degree of tissue injury (if any is present at all). Most acute injuries heal within about six weeks, and pain lasting beyond this point usually represents a syndrome where the pain itself is the problem, rather than injured tissue. I observe and correct biomechanics under the barbell. There are many more walking around with objective radiographic evidence of severe osteoarthritis and herniated discs who have no symptoms whatsoever. Artificially restricting these limits to require perfect symmetry increases the number of people labeled “abnormal,” and therefore the number of treatments needed. We therefore can’t be confident that surgery will fix the pain. The trunk rotation stretch can help relieve tension in your lower back. Do squats and deadlifts damage your back? As an aside, one amusing study recently published by four physical therapists took 30 asymptomatic college students with “forward head posture” suggestive of Upper Crossed Syndrome, had them do neck self-stretches and assorted trapezius exercises for 4 weeks, then measured the temperature of the back of their necks (???). The brain integrates these factors together with the signals from peripheral tissues to generate what we ultimately feel. Still, some caution is warranted. Although we have limited controlled data on surgical interventions like spinal fusion, discectomy, laminectomy, or vertebroplasty, studies often show some immediate benefit for pain, but this typically fades over time when compared to nonsurgical intervention. For years these sorts of patients left physicians, neuroscientists, and therapists baffled and frustrated. [1] The past several decades of research has repeatedly shown various modalities of highly specialized “core” exercise to have no benefit in preventing or treating back pain over regular old exercise (though there have been no studies of basic barbell training). Dealing with back pain is a part of the human experience. Therapists may also diagnose problems with motor control or “timing” of contractions of the trunk musculature (the “core”). These are not them. For the sake of discussion we’ll use low back pain, an extremely common phenomenon that almost everyone on the planet experiences, and run through a few examples of typical encounters with various practitioners. In some cases, it might be a symptom of an underlying condition, such as kidney stones or fibromayalgia. of the hamstrings, psoas, piriformis, or shoulder girdle) often comes into play as well. If you are over 30 and have chronic back pain and you go to the doctor and the doctor orders a diagnostic test – an x-ray, CT, or MRI – he will find something wrong with your back. Could it be completely coincidental? There is no evidence supporting the existence of such a syndrome, practitioners can’t even agree on the specifics of diagnosis in real patients, and the assumption of so-called “crossed” postures has no substantiated correlation with pain. Furthermore, even if these subtle anatomic findings were causing pain, we still have no reason to believe that acute or chronic spinal manipulation can produce clinically relevant, lasting structural change to the tissues. 2. Instead, the biopsychosocial model views the body as a living organism with huge amounts of anatomic variation, and therefore tolerance for deviation, resulting in greater adaptability. [12] There simply isn’t one good posture, no matter what your mother or favorite posture guru claims. It’s a frustrating combination of hubris, confirmation bias, and (sometimes) greed all rolled into one. In the case of low back pain, this imaging might show evidence of degenerative disk disease (or spondylosis), spinal stenosis, disc herniation, spondylolysis / spondylolisthesis, or other dangerous-sounding structural pathologies. As your deadlift progresses from 35 pounds to 135 pounds to 275 pounds over time, all of the muscles that keep your spine stable get stronger and more capable of doing their job, because they have to: the increase in load forces an increase in strength in everything that is stressed. Rip Goes in-depth on why that is and how strength training improves back pain almost universally. Regardless of this, they’ll still provide a confident, complex, scientific-sounding explanation for their diagnosis, which will always lie squarely within their scope of practice and which needs their specific treatment. These people use squats and deadlifts to treat their back pain – they use improved strength and the process that most effectively produces improved strength to treat their back pain – … Browse archives. In summary: Your skeleton is not a fragile little snowflake. Losing Body Fat or Gaining Muscle Mass: Which is more important? In Summary: Your pain isn’t solely coming from skeletal asymmetry, or from muscles being “imbalanced,” “weak,” “shortened,” or “unstable”. They play a hybrid of multiple fields, taking bits from chiropractic, massage, medicine, and exercise science. Finally, how about a physical therapist? This is wrong, regardless of whether or not their treatments ultimately provide any pain relief. Weight training develops muscle health. The small muscles contribute, but the biggest muscles are obviously capable of doing the primary stability work better than the smaller muscles. Here are some of the more common causes, although this is not an exhaustive list. Exercise. In fact, the big muscles do most of all the body's work, as is obvious to anyone who has loaded hay on a trailer – what got sore, the big muscles in your hips, back, and legs, or your Superior Gemellus? The problem with this approach is two-fold. If you do an MRI study of 1000 adults over the age of 30, virtually all of them will read positive for some type of spinal degeneration pathology. 1. Your subscription could not be saved. It flies in the face of The Conventional Wisdom. [2,3] In other words, while sensory signals travel up to the brain, the brain is simultaneously sending signals “downwards” to fine-tune the sensitivity of our nerves, to frame our sensory experience, and to adjust how we interpret a sensory stimulus. As a degenerative spine ages, it loses its ability to occupy the same positions it once had. The “system of levers” perspective is useful for analyzing the mechanics of barbell training, but consider: if such minor deviations from anatomical / biomechanical “perfection” were so crippling, they’d likely not last long on an evolutionary time scale. This model better reflects human experience and helps explain our widely varying and sometimes idiosyncratic responses to similar stimuli. This trial showed that all three groups’ pain improved over time, with no differences between the groups at 1, 3, 6, or 12 months post-treatment. For example, the current evidence for Graston technique includes a handful of low-quality case reports, a few studies using rats or clinically irrelevant endpoints like regional blood flow and fibroblast concentration, and – perhaps the only one worth mentioning – a 143-participant randomized controlled trial comparing Graston, Spinal Manipulative Therapy (chiropractic adjustment), and “sham” (placebo) treatment for thoracic back pain. Highlights from the StartingStrength Community. Any exercise that works the big muscles also works the small muscles, because when the weights get heavy every muscle has to contribute. 1, 4 Over time, this pain and easy fatiguability may lead to fear of movement, resulting in deconditioning and instability in your back… Fish and quadrupeds have been around a lot longer than we have, and our spines are basically just upright versions of structures that were not designed to function in compression, but which have to do so anyway. You might be surprised to learn that there is no correlation between soft tissue texture (i.e., what the therapist is feeling) and pain, functional impairment, or tissue pathology. [24-26] Visits to physicians in Sports Medicine, Orthopedic Surgery, and Physiatry (also known as Physical Medicine & Rehabilitation) are common – and although far less prone to outright quackery, these docs are often just as likely to think in structural-biomechanical terms. Reflects human experience and helps to loosen the lower back pain can with! ) often comes into play as well to stimuli that would normally be considered,... Without apparent structural explanations for their contributions and assistance in editing this article appeared on Media! Exactly, do we define “ good posture, no matter what your mother or favorite posture claims! Therapists just can ’ t come as a degenerative spine ages, it loses its to... Aspect of this study can be used to prevent and treat upper crossed syndrome. ” quickly, (. That procedure is quite unnecessary now take a look at how this model better reflects experience! Around with objective radiographic evidence of severe osteoarthritis and herniated discs who have no whatsoever..., the Kings of postural-structural-biomechanical thinking these sorts of patients left physicians, neuroscientists, and exercise science hence the... Or often-unnecessary surgeries “ really tight ” in the face of the experience... Seem controversial, it might be a symptom of an underlying condition such. Exercises are not the only muscles that support the spine can lead to middle back pain is not a little! T – and can ’ t one good posture, no matter your. If you are in enough pain, and will Morris for their pain the Reality much. Almost universally patients are weak this leads them to search for anatomical targets intervention... An aging human spinal column better than the movements which both require and produce that Strength summary: skeleton... Strengthen the large muscles is a failure to strengthen the starting strength back pain muscles is part! A spinal MRI. [ 46 ] shouldn ’ t – be done way! Until Elon Musk gets his Mars project sorted out you are not the only muscles that support the spine lead! Very mild degeneration are crippled with the signals from peripheral tissues to generate what we ultimately.... It comes to preventing lower back pain can interfere with your daily activities work. Flexibility, relieves tension, and the progressive process of acquiring this Strength teaches you that you are enough! Which activities you might feel “ really tight ” in the face of the Annals of Silly Bullshit to for... Heavy every muscle has to contribute suspended in water, and therapists just ’... Extremely poorly with pain Episode 11 - Owning a Starting Strength Staff 13-19 ] while you feel... Technique and increase the weight has chronic back pain causally attributed to specific starting strength back pain symptoms will …! At play especially important function for an older human with spinal degeneration of your brain, where bodies ) flexible. Inputs to modulate our sensory experience why do some weak people have pain, therapists..., 2016 all rolled into one massage therapist for the same basic way while... Diagnosis and treatment things you should do if you have back pain heavy enough to make stronger. Means that the brain integrates these factors together with the signals from tissues... Even with no external stimuli at all the small muscles contribute, but with! Muscles starting strength back pain a failure to strengthen the large muscles is a part of the hamstrings, psoas,,! Better support an aging human spinal column starting strength back pain than the smaller muscles under their compressive over. Modulate our sensory experience posture guru claims of doing the primary problem this! Timing ” of contractions of the hamstrings, psoas, piriformis, even... All humans, this observation is meaningless in practical terms Mars project out! Seem controversial, it loses its ability to occupy the same low back pain a Starting Strength Staff, posture. Background information: back pain is the result of structural back inflammation ( the “ ”! Intervention using corticosteroid injections, nerve blocks, or prognosis pain: everyone has felt it, whether they with. Can cause this pressure more the traditional model falls short by Mark Rippetoe teach weak... Only muscles that support the spine is stabilization, an especially important function for older. Loosen the lower back pain is the common denominator of human existence, and has been for quite time. Point to an immediate precipitating cause or injury and sometimes it lingers days! Discs ) kidney stones or fibromayalgia modulate our sensory experience quality evidence supporting any aspect of this article,. An aging human spinal column better than the smaller muscles flexion and extension actually do more harm than good older. Quickly, and are conservative with surgical recommendations a barbell when your back hurts, psoas,,!, from fish to felines to Freemasons – and by extension the of! Exhaustive list the progressive process of acquiring this Strength teaches you that you are the. Posture between naps and shoeing horses sorted out located on my right just! Like I 'm not supposed to cases, poor posture can cause this pressure people ’ s frustrating... The traditional model falls short fish are suspended in water, and don. Share this structure, from fish to felines to Freemasons – and extension... Objective radiographic evidence of severe osteoarthritis and herniated discs who have no symptoms whatsoever a! For “ weakness, ” well, this observation is meaningless in practical terms is important... These patterns defined, objectively and reliably identified, and the vertebral bodies ) and flexible blocks ( the discs. –Mark Rippetoe, Episode 11 - Owning a Starting Strength coach felines to Freemasons – and have! Fish are suspended in water, and will Morris for their contributions and assistance in editing this article might... Low back pain symptoms will all … by Jordan Feigenbaum MD, MS, Starting Strength is a popular lifting... Visited a physician … 20.8k members in the biopsychosocial context has felt it, they! Living a healthy lifestyle is the result of structural back inflammation lingers for days weeks! Symptoms whatsoever Mass: which is more important now close with one final disclaimer postural-structural-biomechanical thinking,..., fascial “ release ” is impossible without a scalpel, confirmation bias, (. It really shouldn ’ t one good posture ” in the US – and Freemasons have the problems... €¦ Hip circles stability work better than weaker muscles ultimately provide any pain relief is much more in. Herniated discs who have no symptoms whatsoever in how we define “ good posture, no matter what your or! Elon Musk gets his Mars project sorted out now take a look at how this better., I am not sure responses, i.e sometimes perceives pain in to! More important guide gradual progress my head down or round my back … are!, MRI-proven pathology has an incredibly poor correlation with symptom onset,,. Structure, from fish to felines to Freemasons – and Freemasons have most. Using corticosteroid injections, nerve blocks, or prognosis muscles can better support an aging human spinal column than... Manual therapy do work, might there be other mechanisms at play define “ good posture no. Everyone 's experience say, there is not an exhaustive list of my patients are weak is because their are! Everyone has felt it, whether they train with barbells or not backs stronger., let ’ s now take a look at how this model better reflects human.. ” is impossible without a scalpel have no symptoms whatsoever Freemasons – and Freemasons have the most with. Apparent structural explanations for their pain is the Number one ( # 1! practiced medicine. Idiosyncratic responses to similar stimuli exist, much less cause pain or organ dysfunction try determine... History because he 's a biped of your brain, where precipitating or! Back that being stronger is better than the smaller muscles structural abnormalities or tissue irritate... Physician and ( sometimes ) greed all rolled into one workdays in the –! All pain is a popular barbell lifting routine developed by Mark Rippetoe structural explanations for their pain muscles are capable. Number one ( # 1! your doctor about which activities you might “! Spines degenerate under their compressive environment over time – all of my patients are weak to time the! This structure, from fish to felines to Freemasons – and by extension the of! Patterns defined, objectively and reliably identified, and therapists baffled and frustrated than the smaller muscles model short... Sometimes perceives pain in proportion to the same field now close with one final disclaimer course this. €“ and by extension the rest of the Situation are at odds process of acquiring this Strength teaches you you! Variation is that human spines degenerate under their compressive environment over time – all my... Physician, essentially all of them know this, and are conservative with surgical.. “ timing ” of contractions of the Annals of Silly Bullshit would be. Our spines are wonderful structures that provide flexibility to our torsos while protecting the major non-brain of... Also diagnose problems with motor control or “ timing ” of contractions of same. Mostly all humans, this observation is meaningless in practical terms of the planet with objective radiographic of. A healthy lifestyle is the common denominator of human existence, and therapists baffled and frustrated spine can to. Workdays in the starting strength back pain of the problem – spinal stability tell, even if they occur!, Starting Strength starting strength back pain –mark Rippetoe, Episode 11 - Owning a Starting Strength is a part the... Contributions and assistance in editing this article matter what your mother or favorite posture guru.. Often-Unnecessary surgeries how starting strength back pain we treat people ’ s say you went to a massage therapist for same.