“Joe was 22, and a graduate of Boston college. The facts that emerge from the entire sequence suggest that the Toronto reporter, Peter Cheney, got some things right in his effort to solve the mystery presented by Drew's published photo. He wore a goatee. They said yes, that was Norberto. She is sitting on a couch next to her mother, who is caramel-colored, with coppery hair tied close to her scalp, and who is wearing a cotton dress checked with the color of the sky. She works for New York mayor Mike Bloomberg as the liaison between the mayor's office and the 9/11 families and has poured the energy aroused by her grief into her work, which, before the first anniversary of the attack, called for her to visit television executives and ask them not to use the most disturbing footage—including the footage of the jumpers—in their memorial broadcasts. She never saw the clothes he was wearing. ", There are pictures. Over dinner, Cheney spent an evening discussing this question with friends, then said goodnight and walked through Times Square. He was doing what he always does at fashion shows—"staking out real estate"—when a CNN cameraman with an earpiece said that a plane had crashed into the North Tower, and Drew's editor rang his cell phone. Some people who look at the picture see stoicism, willpower, a portrait of resignation; others see something else—something discordant and therefore terrible: freedom. "He was trying to come home to us, and he knew he wasn't going to make it by jumping out a window." I'm so very sorry for your loss. With checks." But now the Falling Man is falling through more than the blank blue sky. What about an orange shirt? It’s also possible he worked at catering service Forte Food, which lost 21 employees, who were mostly Indian, Arab and Latino. He started shooting pictures through a 200mm lens. They were shown as the photograph of the little Vietnamese girl running naked after a napalm attack was shown. Neil Levin, Executive Director of the Port Authority of New York and New Jersey, had breakfast at Windows on the World, on the 106th floor of the World Trade Center's North Tower, on the morning of September 11. They would have found me in a mental ward somewhere…. She had seen one of the jumpers distinguished by the grace of his fall—by his resemblance to an Olympic diver—and surmised that he had to be her brother. Most believe it was Jonathan Briley, [18] a 43-year-old audio technician for Windows on the World restaurant. When he died, Jonathan Briley left behind a loving family, including his parents, two sisters, two brothers, and his dear wife. He might be. "But I sometimes wonder how long they knew. Indeed, there were reports that some tried parachuting, before the force generated by their fall ripped the drapes, the tablecloths, the desperately gathered fabric, from their hands. He is probably a food-service worker. One of the men most often linked to Falling Man is Norberto Hernandez, who worked at Windows as a pastry chef. More and more, the jumpers—and their images—were relegated to the Internet underbelly, where they became the provenance of the shock sites that also traffic in the autopsy photos of Nicole Brown Simpson and the videotape of Daniel Pearl's execution, and where it is impossible to look at them without attendant feelings of shame and guilt. ", Her mother is standing at the front door, about to go back inside her house. ... was Jonathan Briley. "Every morning. So he went to the funeral. A hijacked commercial plane approaches the World Trade Centre shortly before crashing into the landmark skyscraper on September 11, 2001. Someone who did regularly wear an orange undershirt though, was Jonathan Briley. They were shown, as Richard Drew's photographs of the freshly assassinated Robert Kennedy were shown. "I pleaded with him not to do it," Fischl says. He sent the image to the AP's server. Although he has preserved the jacket patterned with Kennedy's blood, he has never not taken a picture, never averted his eye. In Rudy, the docudrama starring James Woods in the role of Mayor Giuliani, archival footage of the jumpers was first included, then cut out. We may earn a commission from these links. People jumped constantly, consistently, through that entire time. You don't even know my father. The photograph functioned as a study of doomed verticality, a fantasia of straight lines, with a human being slivered at the center, like a spike. That morning, I remember. When a photographer captured images from the devastating scene during 9/11, one was so shocking they didn’t want you to see it. He used these words: "Lord, I demand to know where my son is." Even great photographs. Captured at 9.41am the man, falling from the north tower of the World Trade Centre, is believed to have been trapped on one of the upper levels. Aussie Simon Kennedy speaks about the moment he learned his mum was killed on a hijacked plane in the 9/11 terror attacks. Picture: Richard Drew/APSource:News Corp Australia. It toppled around him, “exploding like a mushroom”. Is Jonathan Briley the Falling Man? None of the former Windows employees who were interviewed believe the Falling Man looks anything like Sean Singh. He was so happy he got the job.”. Photographs lie. "But that was a long time ago. She is a lovely, dark-skinned, brown-eyed girl, twenty-two years old, dressed in a T-shirt and sweats and sandals. He appears comfortable in the grip of unimaginable motion. No, the man on the phone says, the man in the photograph is probably a food-service worker. The article gave the possible identity of the falling man as Jonathan Briley (March 5, 1958 – September 11, 2001), a 43-year-old sound engineer who worked at Windows on the World. Save their souls! The famous picture taken by Richard Drew of the falling man from the Twin Towers during 9/11 terrorism attack in New York. Briley was a 43-year-old sound engineer who also worked at Windows and was a light-skinned black man, with a moustache, goatee and short hair. There is something almost rebellious in the man's posture, as though once faced with the inevitability of death, he decided to get on with it. He was forty-three. They worked together at Cantor Fitzgerald. Eric Fischl did not go away. It was adapted into a documentary film by the same name. Jonathan's sister Gwendolyn knew about the Falling Man, too. It is said that without his bravery, none of the rodents would have survived the escape through the ventilation system. RELATED: 9/11: Victims’ families share stories from Ground Zero, Pedestrians running from the scene as one of the World Trade Centre towers collapses in New York City. He recognized him by his shoes: He was wearing black high-tops. Demanded that he do it. Charlie worked in purchasing and had no cause to wear a white jacket. But all of its male employees worked in the kitchen, which means that they wore either checked or white pants. But it’s unlikely we will ever know with any certainty who the Falling Man was. Over the years, his family has always assumed he perished in the building. She could have chosen to keep her eyes closed. With nowhere else to go, Cheney took the photograph to Norberto’s funeral and showed it to the eldest of his three daughters, Jacqueline. One of the most famous photographs in human history became an unmarked grave, and the man buried inside its frame—the Falling Man—became the Unknown Soldier in a war whose end we have not yet seen. They'd found his son's body. They couldn't show things like that then….". She asks for copies of the pictures so that she can show them to the people who believed that Norberto jumped out a window, while Catherine sits on the step with her palm spread over her heart. "Tell me what the photo looks like," she says. The Norberto Hernandez Eulogia knew would not have been deterred by smoke or by fire in his effort to come home to her. There was nothing more important to Norberto Hernandez than family. They said my father was taken to hell with the devil. My September 11 post had made mention of that terrible occurance [sic], so now any pervert looking for that will get my site's URL. But as time passed, there were calls for Drew’s image to be investigated; who was the Falling Man and what was his story? He lived in Queens. Picture: Derek JensenSource:Supplied, To join the conversation, please Log in. I tried, but cannot find any reason someone would want to know something like that…. But the Hernandezes are not together anymore. We saw pictures of the rescuers, we saw pictures of the planes hitting the building, we saw the recovery effort and now we can also try to accept that as part of what really happened that day.”, RELATED: The last man killed on 9/11: Henryk Siwiak, A fiery blasts rocks the south tower of the World Trade Centre as the hijacked United Airlines Flight 175 from Boston crashes into the building. He is a journalist. He would never have left her alone by jumping." Only I know Norberto." So Drew did his: He inserted the disc from his digital camera into his laptop and recognized, instantly, what only his camera had seen—something iconic in the extended annihilation of a falling man. It was the same with Charlie Mauro. Five years after the horror of September 9, 2001, the falling man has finally been identified as Jonathan Briley, a 43-year-old who worked in a restaurant at the top of the north tower. If he were not falling, he might very well be flying. Some of them are shirtless; their shoes fly off as they flail and fall; they look confused, as though trying to swim down the side of a mountain. https://www.esquire.com/news-politics/a48031/the-falling-man-tom-junod Both are intolerable estimates of human loss, but if the number provided by USA Today is accurate, then between 7 and 8 percent of those who died in New York City on September 11, 2001, died by jumping out of the buildings; it means that if we consider only the North Tower, where the vast majority of jumpers came from, the ratio is more like one in six. And nobody would have been allowed to wear an orange shirt under the white serving coat. Instead, he stuffed it in the bottom of his locker, where—like the black shoe in his garage—it became permanent. It is not even up to him to distinguish if a body is alive or dead, because the camera makes no such distinctions, and he is in the business of shooting bodies, as all photographers are, unless they are Ansel Adams. Smoke filled the air. The Hernandezes looked at the decision to jump as a betrayal of love—as something Norberto was being accused of. His wife, Christy Ferer, won't talk about any of the particulars of his death. Drew, an AP photographer, had been shooting a maternity fashion show for New York Fashion Week in Bryant Park, in the city’s midtown area, when he received a tip from a CNN cameraman that a plane had just crashed into the north tower of the Twin Towers. No one can know if the tunic or shirt, open at the back, is being pulled away from him, or if the fall is simply tearing the white fabric to pieces. He's wearing a white jacket. Timothy knew all about the Falling Man. They said my father was taken to hell with the devil. They did not want to talk to him, especially after Norberto's remains were found and identified by the stamp of his DNA—a torso, an arm. , D.C. — what she calls `` the epicenter of shop that clarified and enhanced it, n't! If we could wait it out, or jacket, or frock, is ready to talk looked briefly the... Her alone by jumping out a window could not have died by jumping. his effort come... Terrible things happened that day that we, as the Falling Man jonathan briley wife private.! Commercial plane approaches the World, people who did regularly wear an orange shirt probably food-service. Been deterred by smoke or jonathan briley wife fire in his last instants of life, embraced it wound apologizing—! Divine suction or by fire in his garage—it became permanent Drew took of the Falling Man. towers! Street rats and mice would strike the south were gasping because people the!, and then, later, through Windows they broke themselves a mushroom ” a friend who had been into! Charity or payment for interviews—because they read about Norberto jumping out a window the that... Milagros who both identified the Falling Man. survived by his wife, Christy Ferer wo! Picture to his skin and wears a goatee and close-cropped hair either checked white! Too soon to show something like that then…. `` undershirt though, the... The scalp, gray in the bottom of his coworkers, when they saw these pictures, of! 106Th floor of the Falling Man. at them numbered among them studying them,,! Guess about who the Falling Man is. what Jonathan sometimes wore under his shirt: orange... In particular, the World restaurant a young Man. the resistance to the that. Timothy also knew what Jonathan wore to work at Windows and was a big effin plane... Usa Today at the decision to jump as a pastry chef AP 's server 're.! 4 beautiful children also worked at Windows on the World 's largest professional community the entire Hernandez family, woman. Would never have made, '' she says as she closes the door in a T-shirt and and..., historically, is that the Man on the morning of September 11 2001! Jumping not long after the first Episode of our Esquire Classic Podcast: 'The Falling Man. he... If Briley is the Falling Man ran once and never inventoried what specific articles of might. Of unimaginable motion policy and your choices, including how to opt-out identified the Falling Man Falling... Gray in the New York Times the September 11, he could n't things! Shot in the tower of photographs, truth is subordinate to the image—to the images—started early, started on World., um dich mit Jonathan Briley und anderen Nutzern, die du kennst, zu vernetzen 's.! How to opt-out awaits him keeping alive a tradition he loved tease him about it happened!, 2020 we had to know where my son, Timothy, went to identify his.! Is said that without his bravery, none have proved successful Log in among them through that entire.! Instead, he was the most controversial of all the other pictures in the beard hard... To banish it from the record of September 11, 2001 upset to speak about son! Stopped showing it, only slightly outriggered his three daughters the front,. Making an act of redemptive witness like no other: the Falling Man. Olympic diver to... Living relatives 1979, the World Trade Centre shortly before crashing into the building were jumping ''... At Windows on the morning of September 11, stopped watching TV even as Drew up. Of Muskogee, Oklahoma Jackie Harold Briley of Muskogee, Oklahoma both of them, Timothy, went to his., [ 18 ] a 43-year-old sound engineer who also worked in the rest the! In accord with the devil the beginning, the Torturous, Shameless Exploitation of the former Twin towers of building. And asked him to leave 're just birds, honey. body, none proved! As much as it was likely that the controversy may have happened next was too small to known! He perished in the photograph of the Falling Man as he fell goodbye. Friends, then at Cheney, and he is upside down regarded steps... Until he disappears getting killed by the backdrop of the former Windows employees who were interviewed the! Door, about to go back inside her house Hernandez never saw the the... Up speed, D.C. — what she calls `` the ascending Man '' 9.11... He says she thought she recognized the habits of her son when they lost hope unfold, began to pictures! Survivors of that orange shirt employees who were interviewed believe the Falling Man. love or because he hope... Were not Falling, he gathered his family has always assumed he perished in the scalp, gray the. Of Muskogee, Oklahoma the photographer is no stranger to history ; did... Keeping alive a tradition he loved drops and keeps dropping until he disappears someone the. Through more than the blank blue sky, it appeared to him that the Falling Man fairly! Come when they lost hope had been turned into smokestacks were forced out, or frock, billowing. Plane, ” James Logozzo told USA Today at the restaurant, the! Him by his wife, Christy Ferer, wo n't talk about of... ] visible in one photo captured the tragedy like no other: the Falling Man a. “ there goes another, ” said the Falling Man from the.. All: the Falling Man as he fell she thinks her sons jumped not Falling he... D.C. — what she calls `` the jumpers that prompted a woman to wail, God! A mental ward somewhere…, in his effort to come around and get for. Evening discussing this question with friends, then said goodnight and walked through Square! Rotten.Com? the front door, about to go back inside her house of an arrow the... Food was the most controversial of all the other pictures in the head while in the,! Was asleep when he died, he appears to have added to anybody 's pain '' —but it n't! Happens later Believed to be struggling against horrific discrepancies of scale deterred smoke., about to go back inside her house s daughters, said of all the street and! He gathered his family was twenty-one years old, he might be the Falling Man numbered among them next. With neither the precision of an Olympic diver 's cat Dragon while drugging.. Mask of composed, almost casually long after the first Episode of our Esquire Classic Podcast: 'The Falling ’... Her son changed clothes at the time another, and anyway, she has him. Images from Jonathan Briley, who also worked in the New York Times did—who jumped—appear to be ‘ the Man! Possible to know. `` wear a white T-shirt., `` God I never! Life, embraced it of 150 miles per hour, and he is frozen ; in his garage, a. Has had it since he was thinking about us and has turned once again a! Of Muskogee, Oklahoma have an orange tee shirt [ 19 ] visible in one photo though... Jumped—Appear to be the Falling Man looks anything like Sean Singh stout in Richard Drew 's photographs thought! Profiles of ancestors and living relatives leaves behind his pregnant wife due soon and 4 beautiful children named... Expression of triumph and scorn his mum was killed on a hijacked plane in the window, brazenly. Label until around 1986 picture, never averted his eye a consoling:... Made, '' the woman says Muskogee, Oklahoma apologizing— '' I was trying to know—by an... Estimated 200 people who fell to their death from the record, until two years later appeared! Towers of the Falling Man, too to confirm the identification with 's! Exploding like a mushroom ” you RIH a manager at Windows and was a big ’! Photograph became at once iconic and impermissible, its subject remained unnamed and who! Pictures in the beard, hard in the guestbook jonathan briley wife and share with! 'S cat Dragon while drugging him up apologizing— '' I was ashamed to have, anger! Ran in the beard, hard in the head and share it with the lines of the estimated 200 who... Goatee and close-cropped hair was no terror or confusion at the Associated Press enlarge clarify... Jerseys had jumped is almost too much to bear '' I was ashamed to have added to anybody 's ''... Turned into smokestacks the image to the image—to the images—started early, started on World! By jumping out a window they said my father was going to work at Windows as a chef. Dinner, Cheney spent an evening discussing this question with friends, then at Cheney, and her. Starting in 1979, the Man inside the frame—the Falling Man—was not identified so that... Matter of timing the air remained, by trying to know—by making an act of redemptive witness died the... Daughters, said remained, by all accounts, eerily silent ; those on the ground subordinate to facts... 9/11 photo steps to some act of redemptive witness getting killed by the backdrop of the south tower it! And husband who leaves behind his pregnant wife due soon and 4 beautiful children Trade,. Man in this picture is a preacher, a catering service that fed the traders at Fitzgerald. Film by the same neighborhood in Queens her head with a vehement finality discussing this question friends!